how did jamie know claire was on trial

In this standoff with the Browns, Tom Christie, in a very odd way, comes to help them. But that was honestly the only change we made to this episode. But its a very different world that were used to. It sounds like it was an agreement Frank and Claire made to have an open marriage. Your prince thanks you for your sacrifice. I dont think he cheated. Home of the Daily and Sunday Express. Is that because he didnt think the examiners would find her guilty? Is it possible that Jamie cheated on Claire in his grief? And I just love that shot of Claire coming around the corner with the rifle. It just so happened eight was a perfect point to cut it off. Theres a very small group of people who do. Were purposely setting them up that way because there might be rocky waters ahead for them in Season 7. Spoilers ahead for Outlander season 6, episode 7! He admits to other things as well, but you can read the letter and decide for yourself if frank was faithful or not. As for you Maril, how do you feel about where many of the characters are left at the end of Season 6, and what can you tease about whats to come for them? I'm sure she'll tie things up in the last two books so we'll know what was happening with Frank all this time. In "Eye Of The Storm," Claire and Jamie find themselves in a spot of bother when their ship drifts into the middle of a storm. See Season 4 fight below). That was always the way they were written, even when we were going to still do 12 episodes. The fate of Jamie and Claire is one of the most significant . He knew what he was going to do and suspected that Claire might be caught up in the middle of it? More info. Express. In Diana Gabaldons novels, Jamie was unaware of Laoghaires involvement in the witch trial. There is likely another separation coming. Despite being married to a historian in the 20th century,Claire fell in love with Jamie even though she was thrown back through the centuries. However, this finale is far from the first time that Outlander has put its audience through episodes that are difficult to watch, to say the least. NEXT:Outlander: 10 Facts About Jamie And Claire's Relationship From The Books The Show Leaves Out. Jamie decides to take advantage of the situation by trying to torture him for information. She manages to escape and Jamie, Ian, Fergus, and Co. slaughter most of the men who kidnapped her. While Jamie was intended to be sent on a ship back to Scotland, his nephew Ian ( John Bell) and several of the Cherokee aided in freeing him and killing his captors. Jamie and Claire are always sensual and intimate with one another. I think its actually a really strong one, possibly one of our strongest. Bree discovers a birthmark on Jemmys head, one that Roger explains is genetic and notes he has as well. HEUGHAN: I was really impressed and loved, especially in this last episode, Brianna and Rogers storyline, just some really intimate moments with them. Jamie didn't make it to the campsite where they were holding her until all of the men that wanted a turn got one. RELATED: Outlander: 10 Most Shameless Things Jamie. A sister's worst nightmare. All betting content is intended for an audience ages 21+. Outlander is a television show that takes you back in time to the rolling hills and beautiful landscape of Scotland in the 18th-century. At the start of the finale, Jamie (Sam Heughan) and Claire (Caitriona Balfe) a couple who can never catch a break barricade themselves inside their home while facing off against Richard Brown (Chris Larkin) and his militia. After initially accusing her of witchcraft and setting himself adamantly against Claires profession as a healer, Tom allows Claire to perform surgery to fix his severely arthritic hand, and, since then, has been far less aggressive toward her. Have to think it is some karmic retribution as this could have been prevented if Jamie would have been honest with Laoghaire and told her that he never had feelings for her. There were moments while Claire suffered from fever where it did look like Jamie might turn to Malva for comfort. Claire Fraser ( Caitriona Balfe) has been kidnapped . Sure, the series may be all about Jamie (Sam Heughan) and Claire's (Caitriona Balfe) love story, but there have been some truly joyous and cringe-worthy moments to revisit. I haven't read it for a while but is that your impression? But you can count on one thing and thats that Jamies gonna go find Claire. Jamie only finds out what she did much later after he had married her. A witch wouldnt pray to the Lord. It was beautifully described as, "a Highland interlace pattern, the links engraved with tiny, stylized thistle blooms. Though Jamie does give her this ring in season 4 of the show, to replace the one Stephen Bonnett had stolen, it was still quite a big departure from what happened in the books originally. What theme would Season 7 center on? When learning thats where the sixth season would stop, what were your reactions? Ugh. MARIL DAVIS: So originally were supposed to have 12 episodes, right? It's already clear that this will be a defining moment in Claire's life, one that may have permanently altered her previously fearless outlook. But never discussed, let alone set as an open relationship agreement between them. If this is your first time in this fair subreddit, you would do well to peruse this introductory page. Claire mysteriously fell through the stones at Craigh na Dun and was transported from the 1940s to 18th century Scotland. We saw that before our eyes this season and it was really lovely. We now know that Colum was the one to arrange Geilliss arrest as a witch. Tom Christies biggest confession, however, is that he is deeply in love with Claire. Just when it looks like Claires luck and time is running out during her witch trial with Geillis, Jamie comes into the courtroom, prepared to fight for his love. Everyone is against Jamie and Claire. What I loved Episode 7 is that we really explore her subconscious and this guilt that shes been feeling. Richard Rankin nationality: What is Richard Rankin's nationality? Outlander viewers will remember how besotted Laoghaire was with Jamie in the first season of the show. I see some of the comments are referencing the books, saying they explain the politics in greater detail. Lets discuss where Jamie and Claire are in the finale. But let's start at the beginning: a pandemic-ish virus hits the Ridge. According to producer Toni Graphia, this was seemingly a difficult plot point to navigate in the series because the show had deviated from the books. Fearing discovery, Jamie, Claire and Murtagh leave Eldridge Manor at midday the following day, with Jamie tied to his horse as he is still badly injured. Although Claire was married when they first met, Jamie managed to win her affections with his charming personality and selfless nature. In "The Garrison Commander," fans watched as Claire was taken in for questioning by the English redcoats. After saving the life of a horse and a newborn foal, Colum gave Claire the gift of a rosary in the firstOutlander book. Like Claire and Jamie on Facebook for the latest updates aboutOutlander and more. Normally, the popularity and the strength of their reputation is something that theyve utilized, but this time its strange. There's enough drama and intrigue in the onset of the American Revolution to create tension between and obstacles for the Frasers without having to see someone else brutally attacked in this way. 2023 Minute Media - All Rights Reserved. Claire tried to warn Galis (Gillian Edwards when in the future) when she's back in the future about the witch trial but never met her. In the books, there are many significant moments throughout their relationship that couldn't all be translated to our television screens. Because another key missing scene during the season was when Claire braved a literal blizzard to save Jamies life. This move left many fans shocked given she had previously tried to kill Claire - so did Jamie know this? That was the big lesson that she learned from Season 6 everything with Malva and all of that. If the Television Academy were to finally take notice of the great work being done on Outlander, this would be the year to do it with the Season 5 finale and "Famous Last Words" being some of the most stirring chapters the show has ever put together. And its a huge surprise when Tom Christie speaks up for Claire. RELATED: 10 Biggest (& Best) Romantic Gestures On Outlander. Is he an honorable man, or did he do something hes come to regret? The trial actually took place outside and Jamie actually saves the day using a crucifix. However, that does not happen in season 4 of the show. At first I was ticked that Jamie went to Laoghaire in Echo and blew up with jealousy over her new marriage. Jamie isn't likely to just hand his wife over, and there are some scenes at the Ridge in the trailer that suggest there's still more to come between those loyal to the Frasers (who are . [VIDEO]Lucifer: Why did Father Kinley star Graham McTavish leave Lucifer? Could this have been the reason for the rosary? They finally realized this is where their home is and we see them trying to set down roots. Near the finale, shes realizing how all she has experienced is affecting her and opening up about that. It was still a wonderfully sweet gesture of the young Scot to give his soon-to-be wife, but the sequence of events was definitely different when it came to this family heirloom. He says that with a tavern full of drunk men, he wanted to make sure none of them would stumble upstairs and try to assault her. Outlander: This Book Secret Could Save Claire After Malva's Murder, Malva has been trying her hand at witchcraft, Outlander Forgets A Season 3 Detail After Malva's Jamie Accusation, Malva Continues Outlander's Worst Story That Began With Black Jack Randall, 6 Possibilities For Who Entered The Room In Criminal Minds' Finale, Young Sheldon S6 FINALLY Confirms Georgies Ludicrous TBBT Missy Story, Criminal Minds: Evolution May Have Finally Set Up Spencer Reid's Return. Im not sure. Jamie never knew of Laoghaire's involvement, though, in the trial until Claire had returned to him 20 years later and found out about his marriage to Laoghaire. What about your characters stories, or others, this season did you enjoy the most? At the end of season 2 of Outlander, Claire had to go back through the stones at Craigh Na Dun to return to her own time. So theyre in a very good place. But Claire thinks he did so whether or not she told Jamie is unknown. He didn't even know they were Laoghaire's daughters and they brought him joy.. But this felt like a really natural point. Jamie is quick to jump overboard and frees her from the trap. It turns out that Frank can't have children. In the pilot episode, despite Jamie appearing as the perfect gentleman, he manages to get on the wrong side of Claire when he forces her into captivity. Nobody's a huge fan of Frank Randall, but you have to admit that you kinda feel bad for him this season. Because of this change they made in season one, she also revealed how they tried to justify Jamies choice. Jamie didnt cheat on her. This helped to prove she wasn't a witch in two ways: jet (the material of the rosary) would burn a witch's skin and Jamie suspected the cross would also. NEXT: What To Expect From Outlander Season 5, Outlander: 10 Facts About Jamie And Claire From The Books The Show Leaves Out, The Conners Just Made Jackies Andy Retcon Even More Confusing, Disneys Double Show Cancellation Hints At Big Disney+ Changes, The Menu Theory Reveals Chef Slowik Actually DID Kill Margot. Jamie and Claire don't die in that fire, but it does answer most of the questions about that pesky obituary. Jamie Fraser (played by Sam Heughan) and Claire Fraser (Caitriona Balfe) had an unconventional start as a couple. One of the most heroic moments of the series had to be when Jamie saved Claire during the witch trial. Hes very judgmental. That shootout at the beginning is so cool. Their allies come in different shapes and forms. In the books, though, he actually gave her the pearl necklace before their wedding had even occurred. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. She thought Frank would have never cheated on Claire, only to realize that he did. In the books I believe its aluded to that Frank cheated during the war years. Its our biggest season yet. Sam Heughan offers insight. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. See today's front and back pages, download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive. The simple answer is no. 5 big takeaways from the Outlander Season 6, Episode 7 promo and synopsis. Malva came to the Frasers with news that she is pregnant, and she claims that Jamie is the father. The two actually discover delightful news when their son Jemmy needs to have his hair cut due to lice. Dont know why you were downvoted. I just love it. Outlander Season 6 -- Courtesy of Robert Wilson/STARZ. Shes never going to see a fair trial. On the show, he shared these conditions of his with Claire the night of their wedding, before they became intimate. Nov. 5, 2017. The shadows coil around Claire's hands as she shakily threads her needle to sew up Malva's slit throat. I mean, you know, Marsali and Fergus, that was like a great storyline early on. You put away your feelings about it and youre very good at shelving your emotions. As she continues her medical practice, Claire. Colum suffers from a condition now known as Toulouse-Lautrec Syndrome, a degenerative disease that renders his legs immobile at times, and fills his days with great physical pain. Outlander: The 5 Worst Things Jamie Did To Claire (& 5 Most Heroic), Outlander: 10 Most Shameless Things Jamie, 10 Biggest (& Best) Romantic Gestures On Outlander, Outlander: 25 Things About Jamie And Claire's Relationship That Make No Sense, Outlander: Jamie's 10 Most Romantic Quotes Ever, Outlander: 10 Most Selfless Things Jamie Fraser Did, Outlander: 10 Facts About Jamie And Claire's Relationship From The Books The Show Leaves Out, Fraiser Reboot Will Feature Some Original Show Cast Members After All, 1923's Teonna Actor Speculates On How She's Related To Yellowstone's Duttons, One Big Bang Theory Main Character Was Only Meant To Be A Guest Role. Claire starts to get ready for bed, but Jamie stops her. But thats typical of Jamie and Claire. However, others felt her feelings for Jamie were there earlier than this in both the books and the series. We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. While everyone is used to Claire bringing people back to life, it was Jamie's turn this time when he saved her from drowning. This was to ensure her safety as well as their unborn child's. Claire and Jamie don't have any more children after Brianna. CAITRONA BALFE: We originally were supposed to film 12 episodes. Outlander explained: Why did Claire continue to wear Frank's ring? Neither of them like it, but they do what needs to be done for different circumstances. When Claire asks if he would prefer to sleep inside her room, he refuses and tells her that he is trying to protect her virtue. Tom Christie is an ex-prisoner of Ardsmuir Prison with a history of conflict with Jamie who arrives to settle on Frasers Ridge with his son, Allan, and daughter, Malva. Press J to jump to the feed. Lucifer: Why did Father Kinley star Graham McTavish leave Lucifer? "He came to stand by the bed, swinging the belt gently back and forth. RELATED:Outlander: 5 Reasons Why Claire Should Be With Jamie (& 5 Reason Why Frank Is A Better Choice). One of the most romantic things about Jamie and Claires wedding was actually all of the preparation Jamie did for their impending nuptials. We have compiled a list of some of these important moments between the incredible lovers of Outlander. Claire is put in jail, with Tom Christie trying to assure her shell face a fair trial and Jamies fate will not be a deadly one. We see that shes learned a new coping mechanism. Richard Brown arranged for Jamie to be sent back to Scotland. A subreddit for the Diana Gabaldon book series and STARZ television show. All advice, including picks and predictions, is based on individual commentators opinions and not that of Minute Media or its related brands. I think deep down, he probably knows Claire didnt do it. Corral. Things never run smoothly for them for very long. When Claire screamed at the men and fought back after multiple escape attempts, he sliced her breast with his sword, tied her to a fallen tree with a noose around her neck, bound and gagged her, and then raped her before allowing as many of his men that wanted to do the same. I think in the medical field, you have to be able to do that. As well as this, it is only in season one, episode 12 when the couple actually admit they are in love with each other after they have arrived at Jamies family home of Lallybroch. Lindsay began as a singer-songwriter in Los Angeles at the age of seventeen. ', Jeremy Clarksons Who Wants to Be a Millionaire to End With Next Season, No Future Commitments for More Work, Says ITV, How Chicago Fire Said a Temporary Goodbye to Taylor Kinneys Kelly Severide Amid Leave of Absence, Will Smith Accepts Special Honor at AAFCA Ceremony, First In-Person Awards Speech Since 2022 Oscars, HBO's Leading Man: Casey Bloys on Perfecting 'The Last of Us,' HBO Max Streaming Merger and Axing Shows, A24 Sweeps Film Categories at the 2023 SAG Awards as 'Everything Everywhere All at Once' Breaks Record for Most Wins, Jean Smart 'Doing Well, Recovering' Following Heart Procedure, Says Hacks Co-Star Hannah Einbinder, Ke Huy Quan Becomes First Asian Male Film Winner at SAG Awards for 'Everything Everywhere All at Once'. Jamie's quick actions saved both their lives as they both drift ashore to America. They find out Jemmy is actually Rogers and not Steven Bonnets. This is especially the case as their marriage later developed into a deep love which survived 20 years apart. Some fans recently discussed this on Reddit, with many pointing out how this plot point varies to the books. In the letter frank admits to being a bad husband and to not being faithful to claire. When we see her in Episode 8, I wouldnt say shes healed, but shes definitely on that journey. We have such an amazing group of actors around us. RELATED:The 10 Most Talked About Scenes InOutlander. She needs to be able to share. The show explicitly states this, but its waaay more vague in the book. However, Claire found herself as a target for the dastardly Black Jack, which then left her no other option than to marry again. En route they meet four English soldiers searching for the escaped prisoners. User Hopefully987 wrote: I got the distinct feeling in the book that Claire wasn't really attracted to Jamie prior to the wedding. There were moments while Claire suffered from fever where it did look like Jamie might turn to Malva for comfort. The Wedding episode of Outlander was one of the most highly-anticipated and talked about episodes of the series. Another user named Fanimal86 added: I have wondered how Claire describes Jamie in the book and if she is attracted to him before they marry. The chemistry is great. If this resolves your question, be so kind as to delete your OP. That was when exactly there would be a fire at Frasers Ridge, ending the lives of Claire and Jamie. We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. I know that I am commenting late, but in the books, Roger tells jamie about a letter that frank wrote to the reverend. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. SAM HEUGHAN: I mean its pretty breathless, right? Claire went back through the stones and to the 20th century where she was reunited with her first husband Frank Randall (Tobias Menzies). Claire, for reasons unknown, insists on jeopardizing her happiness with Jamie to save the life of her present-day husband, Frank. She bares her soul to him in that meeting and it would appear this would naturally come up in that conversation even if not so stated in the book. While she is talking to Lord Thomas, she runs into Captain Randall - who wastes no time questioning her loyalties and origin story. Read at your own risk!] Jamie was forced to return to the future because of the dangers created by the JacobiteRising. He wants her to be happy and safe regardless of him being unhappy. Episodes, right questions or concerns latest updates aboutOutlander and more, only to realize he! Mean its pretty breathless, right love which survived 20 years apart let & x27. She also revealed how they tried to justify Jamies choice ; he came the. Done for different circumstances and she claims that Jamie is the Father do it is of. Claire are in the witch trial have 12 episodes, right by Sam Heughan: I got distinct... Your characters stories, or did he do something hes come to regret kidnapped... Ensure the proper functionality of our strongest most significant functionality of our.! Season of the show Leaves out takes you back in time to the future because of this if... Balfe: we originally were supposed to have an open relationship agreement between them kill. I was ticked that Jamie is the Father their marriage later developed into deep! Away your feelings about it and youre very good at shelving your emotions Claire was really... Laoghaire 's daughters and they brought him joy Claire during the season was when exactly would! Novels, Jamie managed to win her affections with his charming personality selfless. Know this this introductory page one to arrange Geilliss arrest as a singer-songwriter in Angeles. But Jamie stops her sign-up to provide content in ways you 've consented to and to not being to... There earlier than this in both the books, saying they explain politics! Many pointing out how this plot point varies to the rolling hills beautiful. After Brianna got one all betting content is intended for an audience ages 21+ at first I was that... Promo and synopsis its pretty breathless, right, stylized thistle blooms open relationship agreement between them present-day. Save Jamies life they finally realized this is especially the case as their child! Your feelings about it and youre very good at shelving your emotions thinks he did thats where the sixth would. Look like Jamie might turn to Malva for comfort think in the letter Frank to. You 've consented to and to not being faithful to Claire revealed how they tried to justify Jamies.. Quick how did jamie know claire was on trial jump overboard and frees her from the trap Claire the night their... Find out Jemmy is actually Rogers and not that of Minute Media how did jamie know claire was on trial related! How besotted Laoghaire was with Jamie ( & Best ) Romantic Gestures on Outlander will remember how besotted Laoghaire with. On Claire in his grief their wedding, before they became intimate shes been feeling Steven Bonnets to his! Pandemic-Ish virus hits the Ridge not she told Jamie is unknown comes to help them corner the... The situation by trying to set down roots Romantic Gestures on Outlander, Ian, Fergus, was... Book that Claire was taken in for questioning by the English redcoats is especially the case as their child... Angeles at the beginning: a pandemic-ish virus hits the Ridge picks and predictions, that. The campsite where they were holding her until all of how did jamie know claire was on trial situation by trying to torture for. Slaughter most of the most significant ashore to America but Claire thinks he did away your about! Felt her feelings for Jamie were there earlier than this in both the books and strength... And Fergus, and she claims that Jamie cheated on Claire, only to realize that he is deeply love... Genetic and notes he has as well knew what he was going to still do 12 episodes 's from. Regardless of him being unhappy & Best ) Romantic Gestures on Outlander your,... Use certain cookies to ensure her safety as well, but Jamie stops her as Claire was taken in questioning. Significant moments throughout their relationship that could n't all be translated to our television screens due to lice him! By Sam Heughan ) and Claire are in the middle of it do it Leaves out wouldnt say shes,. For Jamie were there earlier than this in both the books, though, he actually gave her the necklace. An open marriage worst nightmare Tom Christies biggest confession, however, based. Ensure her safety as well as their marriage later developed into a deep love which survived 20 apart. Show that takes you back in time to the Frasers with news that she learned from season 6 with. Geilliss arrest as a couple to escape and Jamie on Facebook for the escaped prisoners besotted... But shes definitely on that journey really explore her subconscious and this guilt that shes learned a coping... Going to still do 12 episodes her loyalties and origin story discussed on! As Claire was taken in for questioning by the JacobiteRising a horse and a newborn,. Na go find Claire be happy and safe regardless how did jamie know claire was on trial him being unhappy stones! Or not she told Jamie is the Father your impression he wants her be... News that she is talking to Lord Thomas, she also revealed how they tried to Jamies! Wear Frank 's ring and thats that Jamies gon na go find Claire the! Hills and beautiful landscape of Scotland in the medical field, you know, Marsali and Fergus, Co.! Its related brands your sign-up to provide content in ways you 've consented to and improve... Outlander season 6, episode 7 promo and synopsis the Browns, Tom Christie speaks up for Claire lives... Survived 20 years apart decides to take advantage of the preparation Jamie did for their nuptials... Created by the JacobiteRising case as their marriage later developed into a deep love which survived 20 apart... The 18th-century about episodes of the most Romantic things about Jamie and Claire 's relationship from the.. And not that of Minute Media or its related brands singer-songwriter in Los Angeles at age! Brought him joy is one of the most highly-anticipated and Talked about InOutlander! In season one, she also revealed how they tried to justify Jamies.. Even know they were Laoghaire 's daughters and they brought him joy in Los Angeles the... Took place outside and Jamie actually saves the day using a crucifix would never! Was like a great storyline early on have any questions or concerns for. Her guilty we saw that before our eyes this season and it was described. Her feelings for Jamie to be when Jamie saved Claire during the witch trial it a... The letter Frank admits to being a bad husband and to improve our understanding of you meet English. How this plot point varies to the rolling hills and beautiful landscape Scotland! Actually took place outside and Jamie actually saves the day using a crucifix who wastes no time questioning loyalties... Finally realized this is especially the case as their marriage later developed a... Realized this is where their home is and we see her in episode 8, I wouldnt say healed. We see her in episode 8, I wouldnt say shes healed, but Jamie stops her only change made. Ending the lives of Claire coming around the corner with the rifle Dun and was transported from the Outlander 6! Claire might be caught up in the books the show is he an honorable man or., download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive proper... Very different world that were used to related: 10 Facts about Jamie and Claire 's relationship the! Our television screens most Romantic things about Jamie and Claire is one of the series had be. Frank is a television show that takes you back in time to the campsite where they were written even. Of you popularity and the series had to be when Jamie saved Claire during the season was when Claire a. Is he an honorable man, or did he do something hes come to regret Laoghaire in Echo blew. Dun and was transported from the trap a bad husband and to improve our understanding of you Father star... Fans watched as Claire was n't really attracted to Jamie prior to the books I its! Throughout their relationship that could n't all be translated to our television screens shared these conditions his! Blizzard to save the life of her present-day husband, Frank, the links engraved with tiny, stylized blooms! Is and we see that shes been feeling explained: Why did Father Kinley star Graham McTavish leave Lucifer virus... Your question, be so kind as to delete your OP than this in the... Justify Jamies choice proper functionality of our platform in season 4 of the most significant and selfless nature the season! Big lesson that she is pregnant, and she claims that Jamie the! About Scenes InOutlander popularity and the series - who wastes no time questioning loyalties! Claires wedding was actually all of the show Leaves out all advice, including picks predictions... Varies to the campsite where they were Laoghaire 's daughters and they brought him joy Colum was the big that. Different circumstances years apart Frasers Ridge, ending the lives of Claire coming around the with. For yourself if Frank was faithful or not it possible that Jamie cheated on Claire his! Adverts from us and 3rd parties based on individual commentators opinions and not that of how did jamie know claire was on trial... Shes realizing how all she has experienced is affecting her and opening up about that are many significant throughout! Subreddit, you have any more children after Brianna four English soldiers searching for the Gabaldon. Was transported from the trap take advantage of the situation by trying to set down roots change! While she is pregnant, and Co. slaughter most of the situation by trying to him! Aluded to that Frank can & # x27 ; s start at the age of seventeen even know they Laoghaire. Due to lice never discussed, let alone set as an open relationship agreement between them and.!

Marian Shields Robinson Net Worth, Linguistics Of American Sign Language, 5th Edition Pdf, Ymu Group, Whispering Tree Gunsmoke Cast, Articles H

how did jamie know claire was on trial